Creamiest And Tastiest Paneer Brand – Mishry Reviews

review of some popular paneer brands

Creamiest And Tastiest Paneer Brand – Mishry Reviews

We reviewed some of the nation-wide popular paneer brands which are also easily available online as well as offline. By reviewing them based on important parameters like smell, texture, taste, and moisture, this is what we found.

This is the review that’ll help you find the best paneer brand for your cooking purposes. From over 6 popular paneer brands, some of whom turned out to be chewy, crumbly, or off-tasting, we believe that Mother Dairy Fresh Paneer is the deserving winner of our review to find the Creamiest and Tastiest Paneer brand in India.

It was Mother Dairy Fresh Paneer’s moist texture, fresh aroma, and mildly sweet, almost milky sweet taste that contributed to its winning top honors.


Best Paneer Brand To Buy: Mother Dairy Fresh Paneer

Paneer brand - Mother Dairy

Mother Dairy Fresh Paneer, 200g Pack

Mother Dairy Fresh Paneer emerged victorious in our review of top paneer brands. It has a sweet milky smell along with a fresh, natural taste. Moreover it retains its moistness and taste after being cooked as well.

Best Paneer Brand (Also Recommended): Amul’s Paneer

Our Review Process


The Brands We Picked

  1. Mother Dairy’s Paneer
  2. Amul’s Paneer
  3. Gowardhan’s Paneer
  4. Ananda’s Paneer
  5. Arlys’s Paneer
  6. Fidello’s Paneer
Brands Moisture Odor Texture & Color Taste Shelf Life
Mother Dairy No Fresh milky smell Soft, crumbly, and spongy Pleasant milky taste 15 days
Fidelo B Pure No Mildly sour smell Soft Mildly acidic 15 days
Ananda No Very sour smell Hard Mildly sour 15 days
Amul Traces Fresh, cheese-like smell Soft, creamish color Sweet and salty 45 days
Gowardhan Yes, lots of it Sour smell Very hard, rubber-like, creamish color Chewy, acidic aftertaste     60+ days
Arlys No Sour smell Very hard, rubbery Sour and acidic aftertaste 15 days

How We Picked Brands?

Needless to say that the six paneer brands, which we have mentioned, are some of the most popular brands available online as well as offline. Though loose paneer is also quite easily available at most offline stores, due to the lack of information regarding their nutritional content or shelf life, they don’t quite fit in with all the other contenders. Moreover, loose paneer is usually locally produced and supplied by local dairies within a smaller geographical area.

All the paneer brands we picked were easily available at several locations across Delhi-NCR. These are also easily available for audiences outside the national capital region through major online portals as well.

Team Mishry

Who This Is For?

This review is specifically for those who rely on big brands for their needs. For small families, young couples, or even students, this review concerns everyone who buys branded paneer from the nearest supermarket or Kirana shops. Though there might be some families who choose to prepare paneer at home, still this review might provide them with some useful information if need be.

Related Reading: More Milk-Based Product Reviews

Best Packaged Dahi Brand To Buy

Tastiest Mishti Doi Brand To Buy

Best Chaas/Buttermilk Brand To Buy

The Tastier Lassi: Mother Dairy or Amul?

How We Tested:

Before we go any further, we would like to state that taste can be subjective, and what may seem tasty to one person may not be the same for the other. Our tasting process was divided into two different parts, the first of which was the tasting of raw paneer samples from each of the six brands. Each sample was picked blindly so that the biased factor is eliminated and the outcome is justifiable. The second part was the Mishry secret sauce, where we cook a simple paneer dish using different brands.

We cooked with the six brands of paneer to find the tastiest.
 We cooked the 6 brands in batches of 3.

The Parameters Considered:

Parameters are the most important aspect of testing. They are the basis on which each of the brands is tested and judged. As the parameters upon which one judges the paneer are the same, some of these fixed parameters, upon which our paneer review is done, are:

Odor: The smell of the paneer is important, as it tells a lot about its freshness. Most of the fresh paneer would have a certain combination of mildly sour and milky smell.

Texture: It is, in fact, the first thing that you notice after biting into the fresh batch of paneer. Its chewiness and crumbliness heavily influence its overall quality. You want a soft, firm, and moist texture.

Taste: The creaminess, sourness, and aftertaste, are some of the few qualities which we have compared between these six popular brands in order to come up with the one that had the most pleasing taste.

Moist Or Dry: Whether it’s dry or moist, this was indeed an important part of our review. Moist paneer is much easier to cut down and add up to that extra-creaminess of the dish.

Related Reading:

Protein Rich Foods: Benefits, Side-Effects And Easy Dishes To Eat Everyday

Top 10 Benefits Of A Protein-Rich Diet

Protein Rich Food For An Indian-Vegetarian Diet: 10 Food Items Rich In Protein +Recipes

Final Tasting:

After the different paneer brands were blind-tasted, we judged them on the four fixed parameters namely smell, texture, taste, and moisture. Mother Dairy Fresh Paneer seemed to be perfectly moist, with a fresh milk-like odor and milky taste that felt perfectly natural. It not dense and rubbery, unlike a few other brands. There was no trapped moisture or watery whey inside the pack.

We all love paneer, but did you know how much protein is there in paneer?

Mishry Secret Sauce:

Mishry Secret Sauce was the second part of our review process. It doesn’t involve blind tasting, but instead, we decided to use different brands and prepare a simple paneer bhurji recipe using each one of them separately. Such a simple recipe allows the flavor of the paneer to come through without it being overpowered by other spices and herbs.

The brands were divided into two separate batches of three each. After tasting the two batches, Mother Dairy Fresh Paneer and Amul Paneer emerged as the finalist of our paneer-bhurji taste test, as both of these paneers retained their moisture, thus having that creamy texture that we loved. Mother Dairy Fresh Paneer further maintained its fresh taste and emerged as the overall winner, as a result.

Watch this video:

Final Result Of The Mishry Secret Sauce

Out of the two finalists which were Amul and Mother Dairy, mother dairy’s paneer, along with being moist, retained that fresh and mildly sweet flavor that was present in it while it was being tasted raw, and it was very well spotted in the final outcome. Though as we have mentioned, the taste and preference of paneer might differ from person to person, as per our extensive taste tests and reviews, the Top Pick is Mother Dairy Fresh Paneer.

Food & Beverage is a constantly evolving segment with new categories of products being launched daily. Our endeavor here is to help shoppers buy better. Our reviews are unbiased and all samples used during the reviews were paid for by us. Read our entire ethics statement here.

Team Mishry

Team Mishry is our team of researchers, reviewers, digital content producers, and writers who are part of every review in our test kitchen. They test, taste, and tirelessly break down a product's features, discuss pros and cons and arrive at a final verdict after much debate, deliberations and dialogue. All the reviews where crucial inputs have been derived from multiple team members are where the byline belongs to the entire team - Team Mishry!

Comments (3)

  • Dr Sheeba Hussain

    Mother Dairy Paneer is the best

    July 12, 2019 at 10:55 pm
  • Dr Sheeba Hussain

    Mother Dairy Paneer is the best..

    July 12, 2019 at 10:55 pm
  • Santosh

    You should have reviewed ID brand paneer too.

    August 10, 2019 at 1:12 pm

Comments are closed.